Chapter 25: Basic Beliefs and Attitudes, section 4 of 4 Overview of chapter 25 Book contents Previous Next

Why the World Looks Old

What has been said about the hiddenness of God also helps explain why the world, and the life in it, should appear to have come about through a long process instead of in a single day.

Suppose that we dug down into the earth and found that every trace of life, from the smallest to the largest, went back no further than six thousand years, or twelve thousand, or twenty thousand, or whatever recent date one prefers. Suppose there were no trace of life at all before that point and an abundance of solid evidence for it afterward. Suppose geologists told us it was perfectly clear that the earth itself was no more than a few thousand years old, that it had appeared all at once, and that no natural explanation of how this could have happened was even conceivable. Could anyone then doubt that there was a Creator? It would certainly be very difficult. No doubt some would still find a way, but the evidence would leave them almost nowhere to stand.

Yet, as we have seen, God must be hidden. He acts through nature, and in a way that allows doubt to exist, because without the possibility of doubt there is no real choice. There is really no alternative, then, but for the world to look as though it could have come about without Him. Since human beings have the ability to investigate these things, life had to arrive through a process that can be studied, not through a single, total, instantaneous miracle.

The same can be said of the universe as a whole. Suppose it consisted of nothing more than a sun, a moon and an earth, and human beings who wondered how it all came to be, with no conceivable explanation other than a Creator. Again, God would not be hidden. A vast universe, in which “anything” seems possible, and which develops through an orderly physical process, leaves room for doubt. But such a universe must also be old, for two reasons. If it existed for only a short time, the alternative to a Creator would not be believable. And it must be very large, large enough to make “anything” seem possible, which means it must also be old, or we could not see most of it. Light takes time to travel. The light from distant stars and galaxies that reaches us now left them long ago, some of it billions of years ago, and from that alone we can tell that the universe is very old.

An old universe, an old earth and an ancient history of life are therefore not contrary to belief in God, once His purpose for us is understood. They are what that purpose would lead us to expect.

Some believers answer the question differently. The world, they say, really is only a few thousand years old, but God made it look old, complete with fossils, layers of rock and starlight already on its way to us. To others this idea is deeply objectionable, since it would mean that God had planted false evidence in His world and deliberately deceived those who study it honestly. It also resembles the claim we met earlier, that the universe was created one second ago with all its memories and records in place: it cannot be refuted, but it explains nothing.

Nor is there any need for it. Nothing is lost if creation took a long time. A long process is a burden only to one who lives in time and must wait for the result, and God does not live in time. “For a thousand years in Thy sight are like yesterday when it is past” (Ps 90:4). The one real difficulty is the Sabbath, which the Torah links directly to six days of creation. That question will be taken up in the next chapter.

In the end, though, a few billion years of history, looked at with an open mind, is not enough to hide Him. As some of the estimates mentioned earlier suggest, it is nowhere near enough time to accomplish by chance everything the earth contains in the way of life. For one who is searching for God, He is right here, as visible as daylight to anyone willing to see. Both nature and the Torah proclaim Him loudly. He is hidden only from one who would prefer not to see Him. And that, too, is possible, as modern science and biblical criticism have shown.

Creation as a Work of Art

There is one more point to add. A magical creation, in which everything appears fully formed in an instant, is in a sense unremarkable. Of course God can do such a thing. An all-powerful Creator who simply makes the world appear as it is has done nothing that should surprise us, and nothing that we could study. There would be nothing to see.

A universe that unfolds from its beginning is something else. Its history can be reconstructed. Physicists can trace it back to its first moments and see for themselves how precisely everything had to be set, and how ingeniously it all works together. In some measure, we can see what God did. To set the conditions at the very first moment so precisely that from them, over billions of years, galaxies, stars and planets would form, is a work of genius and of art. The same is true of life. To place within a single tiny cell the capacity to become a world full of living things, in all their diversity and astonishing complexity, is far more awe-inspiring, and far more interesting, than a single act that makes everything appear at once. We see the same wonder on a small scale in every human being, each of whom began as a single cell. Whether creation unfolded by the laws set at the beginning alone, or with God’s word guiding it at the turning points, as the next chapter will suggest, it is the unfolding that reveals the artist.

There may be a moral in this as well. The purpose of creation, as we have seen, is for human beings to choose good and so to bring about blessing. A person is expected to master his nature, to do good deeds, and to grow. If a tiny cell can become a world full of life, and a seed can become an oak, then a person, through effort and persistence, can transform himself as well. The Torah itself compares man to a tree of the field (Deut 20:19), and the Psalmist says that “the righteous will flourish like the palm tree; he will grow like a cedar in Lebanon” (Ps 92:13). The story of the world is a story of growth. History is development, and the life of each person is meant to be development too. It is fitting, then, that the story of creation should be a story of development as well.

Not Meant to Be Read Simply

One more reason not to insist on a simple reading of the creation account comes from Nachmanides. He opens his commentary on the Torah’s first verse by saying that the account of creation is a deep secret. It cannot be understood from the verses themselves; it is known only through the tradition handed down from Moses at Sinai, and those who know it are obliged to keep it hidden. If that is so, the opening chapter of the Torah was never meant to be read simply, and perhaps not literally at all. Its plain words are only part of its meaning. What Nachmanides was able to reveal of that tradition will be considered in the next chapter.

Last revised 14 November 2026